After watching and rewatching James Gunn’s Superman trailer in current weeks, I used to be on a Superman excessive. To maintain it going, I made a decision that whereas building a Lego over Christmas break, I used to be going to rewatch all the Christopher Reeve Superman motion pictures. Motion pictures I’d seen earlier than—I’m even sufficiently old to have seen IV in theaters—however hadn’t rewatched so as in many years. What I discovered was one of the crucial rapidly declining franchises I can consider, although I imagine historical past has two of the movies reversed.
Everybody would agree that Richard Donner’s 1978 movie Superman is a traditional. It’s so epic and stuffed with memorable scenes that it nonetheless stands as one of many nice superhero movies of all time. Clearly, it’s the very best of the bunch. Superman II is a step down for sure however it properly completes the story of that film, giving us a full circle with the Clark Kent and Lois Lane characters and wrapping up the entire Common Zod factor.
Then I popped on Superman III and instantly I knew it was a foul choice. It begins with Richard Pryor’s character in an unemployment workplace. He then, magically, turns into the world’s best laptop hacker. Clark Kent goes again to Smallville and will get oddly shut with an outdated classmate. Pryor and his evil boss make pretend kryptonite that’s principally a cigarette and it inexplicably turns Superman into an asshole. Then we’ve got to observe him be an asshole for means too lengthy. Lastly, Superman fights himself, turns into regular once more, and fights the pc hackers whereas additionally inexplicably forgiving Pryor’s character. It’s, to place it bluntly, an enormous piece of shit.
Superman III truly made me offended. If I wished to observe a Richard Pryor film, I might have carried out that. This was clearly simply Richard Pryor starring in a Superman film, not the opposite means round. It misunderstands the characters, by no means develops a dramatic plot, is stuffed with all kinds of out-of-place gags, and works higher as an anti-smoking advert than anything. This apprehensive me enormously as a result of whereas I’d seen Superman and Superman II a couple of occasions lately, I didn’t bear in mind III or IV as properly. All I did bear in mind was, I assumed, IV was the worst of the bunch. So once I began it, I used to be greater than a little bit hesitant.
Getting into with these low expectations, I truly discovered Superman IV: The Quest For Peace to be vastly superior to Superman III. It’s nonetheless horrible—let’s not neglect that—however a minimum of it’s making an attempt to be a Superman film. He’s again in love with Lois Lane, with Margot Kidder again for the entire movie. Lex Luthor has a brand new scheme and Gene Hackman is again for the entire movie. Superman has to combat an otherworldly supervillain in Nuclear Man. And the character is working in direction of the betterment of the complete world. These are all issues that really feel essential, in a method or one other, to the DNA of a Superman film.
After all, all of this occurs means too simply, and not one of the actors—apart from the at all times distinctive Reeve—care one iota about what they’re doing. Superman IV forgets occasions of different motion pictures, appears dangerous, feels one way or the other too small for the franchise, and the motion set items are dreadful. It’s a foul, dangerous film. Nevertheless it’s a step up from the abomination of the earlier one.
Because the movie ended (Superman IV can be about 45 minutes shorter than the earlier three, mercifully, although there are many reasons for that), I felt fairly assured in my rankings. One is one, two is 2, 4 is three, and three is 4. It actually felt like an nearly infallible listing. So, once I regarded over at Wikipedia and Rotten Tomatoes to see that Superman III is best regarded— although not by a lot—than IV, I used to be a little bit shocked. Clearly that’s the narrative I had in my head moving into however watching the 2 dangerous motion pictures again to again, after the nice first and good second ones, I felt like historical past was mistaken. Superman III is terrible in each sense of the phrase whereas The Quest For Peace is terrible, whereas a minimum of attempting to be a Superman film. And that put it excessive.
Fortunately, Warner Bros. does have the proper palate cleanser for these two atrocities. No, not the unofficial sequel Superman Returns from 2006. We imply Tremendous/Man: The Christopher Reeve Story, a fantastic documentary about the man and the character. That would possibly truly be the very best Superman film on the market.
All of those motion pictures are presently streaming on Max.
Need extra io9 information? Try when to anticipate the most recent Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on film and TV, and every thing you should find out about the way forward for Doctor Who.
